William Henry Toodle III, 50, was shot and killed on Sunday afternoon, January 22, 2023, in the 4800 block of East Michigan Street on Indianapolis’ east side. Neighbors reported hearing a disturbance and then gunfire around 1:00 p.m.; when officers arrived they found Toodle lying on the ground. Homicide detectives opened an investigation and identified a potential suspect in the early stages while processing the scene.

On June 9, 2023, Indianapolis police arrested 32-year-old Paul Landrum in connection with Toodle’s death. Marion County Jail records show Landrum was charged with murder, possession of a narcotic drug, and unlawful possession of a firearm by a serious violent felon. Does anyone in the area remember the disturbance that afternoon or have information about what led up to the shooting?