On the evening of April 22, 2023, brothers Jimmy Jermaine Thomas Jr., 29, and Jaquareous Rashawn Tyreik Mitchell, 26, were shot inside a Shell gas station on North Emerson Avenue in Indianapolis. The pair had stopped to pick up a pizza; Mitchell was found dead at the scene and Thomas was critically injured, later dying at a local hospital. Thomas left behind an unborn child.

Indianapolis Metropolitan Police used gas station surveillance footage and a fingerprint on a soda bottle to identify 20-year-old Martice McGee as a suspect. McGee was arrested and initially charged with two counts of murder; the evidence included video capturing the moments before and during the shooting. A neighbor dispute and a robbery of the girlfriend’s apartment shortly after the shooting were mentioned by family and associates during the aftermath.

Does anyone have further information about the brothers’ last hours or the people they were involved with that evening?