On April 22, 2023, Jaquareous Rashawn Tyreik Mitchell, 26, was killed in a shooting inside a Shell station at 34th Street and Emerson Avenue in Indianapolis. He and his older brother, Jimmy Jermaine Thomas Jr., had stopped at the convenience store while running errands to pick up pizza and soda. A confrontation with a third person inside the store led to gunfire; both brothers were shot. Mitchell was pronounced dead at the scene and his brother was taken to Methodist Hospital in critical condition.

Detectives with the Indianapolis Metropolitan Police Department collected evidence at the scene, including fingerprints from a two-liter soda bottle and surveillance footage that investigators say identified a suspect. A 20-year-old named in reports was taken into custody and initially charged in the case. If anyone has information about Mitchell, his brother, or the events that night, please share what is known with investigators.