Andi Wagner, 24, disappeared from the Evansville, Indiana area in early August 2022. On August 6 she was seen by her sister at their grandparents’ home on Stanford Drive for about ten minutes while she packed a bag and later sent a text that would be the family’s last communication from her. She had been staying with her grandparents but also spent time in Newburgh and Oakland City; there are reports she was seen in Oakland City on August 6.

Accounts of the days that followed conflict. A man described as a boyfriend or ex-boyfriend said Andi was at his apartment the night of August 6 and was gone when he woke up. Other witnesses placed the pair together at a party in Oakland City on the evening of August 7, and Andi’s phone reportedly pinged at the man’s location until the afternoon of the 7th. Her family reported her missing to the Evansville Police Department on August 12, 2022, and later criticized the level of attention the case received.

Investigators followed tips including one alleging sex trafficking, prompting FBI involvement and a multi-property search in the Oakland City area in May 2024; a $25,000 reward has been offered. Andi Madison Wagner remains missing. If anyone in Evansville, Newburgh, or Oakland City saw Andi or has information about her movements in early August 2022, please come forward.