Matthew Reagan, 39, and his younger brother Philip were traveling from Ohio to California when their vehicle became stuck near Sawmill on the Navajo Nation. The brothers set out on foot seeking help and were found dead on March 21, 2020. Investigators from the FBI, the Navajo Department of Criminal Investigations, and the Apache County Sheriff’s Office determined both men had been shot; the deaths were ruled homicides.

Matthew was a husband and father of five young sons. The case remains unsolved with no arrests or publicly identified suspects; the FBI has offered up to a $10,000 reward for information leading to arrest and conviction. The motive for the killings has not been established.

Did anyone in the Sawmill area or along travel routes toward California see the brothers or their vehicle around March 2020?