Keith Johnson Jr., 39, was found dead with apparent gunshot wounds on April 9, 2023, on Southeast Greendon Avenue behind Harpers Pub in Port St. Lucie. Police received a 2:02 a.m. call about a shooting in the 1700 block of Southeast Port St. Lucie Boulevard. Surveillance footage shows Johnson leaving the bar at 1:58 a.m., followed by 25-year-old Elijah Inchauteguiz of Port St. Lucie. A witness heard three pops and saw Inchauteguiz pointing a smoking gun at Johnson before fleeing on a motorcycle. Johnson was shot five times and was wearing a shirt indicating likely membership in the Outlaw motorcycle club; the shooting is believed related to a dispute between rival motorcycle gangs.

Inchauteguiz, identified as a member of the rival Unwanted Nomads motorcycle club, was pursued by police into Martin County after refusing to stop and was arrested on Southwest Citrus Boulevard. At arrest he had gunshot residue on his hands and was carrying a six-shot speed loader containing over 350 rounds. He faces charges of murder and fleeing and eluding. Investigators are examining the possible involvement of other suspected Pagans members who followed Johnson outside the bar. If anyone has information about what happened that night or knew Keith, please share tips with investigators.