Jeremiah Aguirre, a 36-year-old Black man from Poinciana who was also known to some as Jay Reed, was shot to death at his Lauderdale Court residence on the evening of January 25, 2024. An intruder forced entry that night and shot Aguirre twice; one bullet struck his abdomen and proved fatal. Relatives discovered his body on Saturday, January 27.

The Polk County Sheriff’s Office investigated and determined the motive was jealousy over a woman. Detectives identified 23-year-old Kwavaughn Armani Buckley as a suspect, obtained a felony first-degree murder and armed burglary with assault/battery arrest warrant, and issued an alert that he drove a silver Chrysler 300 and should be considered armed and dangerous.

On January 30, officers with the Winter Park Police Department arrested Buckley at his residence on the Polk County warrant; he was booked into the Orange County Jail pending transfer to Polk County.

If anyone knew Jeremiah, his routines, or saw a silver Chrysler 300 in the Poinciana area around January 25–27, please share what was seen.