Andrea Nicole Robinson was 29 and living in Hamburg, New York, when she was last seen by her husband on the morning of May 17, 1996. She was scheduled to pick up her child from school but phoned a friend saying her car had broken down and asking that the friend pick up the child; that call was the last known contact. Reports say Andrea had been feeling despondent at the time.

Later that same day personal belongings belonging to Andrea were found on a picnic table at Dufferin Island Park in Niagara Falls, Ontario. Her vehicle was recovered separately in a parking ramp on the American side of the Rainbow Bridge. She is described as a Caucasian female, 5 feet 3 inches, about 110 pounds, with short curly brown hair, green eyes, a birthmark on her lower left leg and surgical scars on both knees. On the day she disappeared she wore beige pants and a pink and white t-shirt.

The items found in Canada and the car found on the U.S. side of the border have never produced a clear explanation. If anyone knew Andrea, saw her on May 17, 1996, or has information about the locations where her belongings and car were discovered, please share what is known.