On the evening of June 26, 1995, 18-year-old Holly Anne Painter vanished from Toronto, Ontario. She was living on her own, had recently completed a co-op placement, and was making plans for the future — she had just had her braces removed and was about to start a rock-climbing course; she even called her mother about picking up her bank card to buy climbing shoes.

That night Holly was with two acquaintances at her residence. The companions say an argument broke out and they all left in a vehicle to take her to her parents’ home. Their account says Holly became upset, jumped out of the car at the intersection of Warden Avenue and Kingston Road and ran off; that was the last reported sighting.

Holly’s bank card was used in Cheektowaga, New York, shortly after she disappeared; a male friend later admitted using the card, saying he had left the country for an immigration matter. Although her body has never been found, the case has been classified as a homicide and investigators say people in the community hold information about what happened but have not cooperated. Does anyone have information about Holly’s last movements or about the people who were with her that night?