In June 2017, three women were found shot to death and partially concealed inside a shed at a rural Caldwell, Idaho, farmhouse. The victims were identified as 48-year-old Nadja Medley, her 14-year-old daughter Payton, and 56-year-old Cheryl Baker. The coroner concluded each had been killed by a single gunshot and had likely been dead for one to two weeks before discovery during a June 19 welfare check.

Investigators quickly focused on Gerald Mike Bullinger, a man who had moved Nadja and Payton from Utah to the recently purchased farmhouse. Authorities revealed Bullinger was actually married to Cheryl Baker and charged him with three counts of first-degree murder. A nationwide manhunt followed; his car was recovered at a remote Wyoming campground in July 2017 but Bullinger himself has never been located. The families remain without final answers.

If anyone knew the women, Bullinger, or saw him in northern Utah or southern Idaho in June 2017, please share what you remember.