Angel Nichole Overstreet was last seen in Huntington, West Virginia, on May 1, 2021, when she was three months old. At the time she went missing she was reportedly in the care of her father, Shannon Patrick Overstreet, though the family’s timeline sometimes lists May 7 or May 8 as the date the disappearance came to light. Child Protective Services reported Angel missing on May 24, 2021, after questioning Shannon about her whereabouts and finding no record or documentation of any transfer of custody he had described.

Investigators quickly focused on the father. On the day Angel was reported missing he was arrested on separate felony malicious wounding and battery charges for an assault on his mother. Law enforcement conducted extensive searches, including draining a pond on Shannon Overstreet’s property in Olive Hill, Kentucky, and later searching a 55-gallon barrel recovered from that Kentucky property. Bone fragments recovered there were later identified as Angel’s, and a grand jury returned an indictment in December 2023 charging Shannon with murder, death of a child by a parent by child abuse, and concealment of a deceased human body. He has pleaded not guilty and remains incarcerated on that case and other charges.

What did anyone in Huntington or Olive Hill notice in early May 2021 that might help explain where Angel was taken or who might have seen her?