Michael Patrick Ahern, 42, was last seen on January 6, 2019, in Stillwater, New York; that day was also the last time his cell phone was used. He was living at the former Rolling Pride Motorcycle Club clubhouse on Brickyard Road and was involved with local motorcycle clubs. Ahern’s green 2003 GMC pickup truck, his medications and his dog were left behind at the clubhouse with no arrangements made for the dog’s care, and those who knew him said it was uncharacteristic for him to leave without warning.

Investigators later concluded foul play was involved. Police say Jack Jeffers, who also lived at the clubhouse, and Ahern were alone at the Brickyard Road address on January 6, 2019, when Jeffers killed Ahern and removed his body from the location. The suspected motive was a personal dispute amid ongoing tensions over drugs and money. Jeffers was linked to the killing through a handgun he was found carrying during a March 15, 2019 traffic stop; investigators say forensic work tied that weapon to Ahern’s death.

Despite a guilty plea and sentence for the person charged, Ahern’s body has not been located and the investigation into what happened after his death remains open. If anyone knew Michael, his routines at the clubhouse, or saw him around Stillwater in early January 2019, please come forward with information.