On the evening of April 7, 2023, a dispute on the 1000 block of Elmira Street in Mobile, Alabama, ended in gunfire and the death of 53-year-old Patrick Orr. Police were called about a shooting at about 6:43 p.m. and found Orr lying on a lawn with gunshot wounds; he was taken to a hospital and later died from his injuries.

Investigators say Orr had been in a physical altercation with another man before the shooting. That man, 53-year-old Samuel Grace, was found at Springhill Medical Center with injuries from the earlier fight. Mobile police arrested Grace and charged him with Orr’s murder; he was taken to the Metro Jail.

Are there witnesses or neighbors who saw the fight or the shooting on Elmira Street that evening who can share what they remember?