Paige Marie Renkoski, 30, disappeared on May 24, 1990, after a day of travel across southern Michigan. She drove her mother to Detroit Metro Airport that morning, visited a friend in Canton, and was seen buying a beer around 2:30–2:45 p.m. The last confirmed sighting was about 3:30 p.m. on the shoulder of westbound Interstate 96 near the Fowlerville exit, where motorists saw her talking with two unidentified men beside a maroon or burgundy minivan. Witnesses described her as distressed at one point; one man was seen with a hand on her shoulder.

Her 1986 Oldsmobile Cutlass Calais was found idling later that evening with the key in the ignition, lights and radio on, driver’s door unlocked, and her purse, wallet, shoes and the beer she had purchased still inside. There was no visible damage to the vehicle. Fingerprints and palm prints recovered from the car have not been matched publicly. Investigators considered theories including possible impersonation of an officer and developed composite sketches from varying witness descriptions, but no arrest has been announced and no body has been found.

What did anyone in the I-96 or Fowlerville area remember about that afternoon or those men near the minivan?