Sandra Sandy Sollie, 38 and seven months pregnant, disappeared from Macedon, New York on May 24, 1994. She was last seen in the afternoon at the Ames Plaza on Route 31 and was not reported missing until June 5 after failing to pay rent. Her Honda remained in the duplex driveway with the door locked; inside, clothes were in the closet and her dog Jessie’s food dish was full, yet both Sandra and the dog were gone.

A few puzzling clues emerged: Sandra’s purse and Jessie’s collar, leash, and tags were found in a dumpster behind a Penfield car wash, and her wallet turned up later in Rochester. Over $1,000 in purchases were made on her credit cards in the Rochester area; the people who used them said they got the cards from a boy who found the wallet and were later cleared of involvement. Friends say Sandra planned to meet her ex-husband Ralph Sollie Jr. that day; he denied involvement and declined a polygraph. A private investigator has worked the case pro bono and investigators searched property once owned by the ex-husband in 2016, but the disappearance remains unsolved.

Sandra’s family and friends believe foul play is likely because it was out of character for her to leave without contact. Anyone with information about Sandra or her unborn son Brandon Michael is asked to contact the New York State Police.