Anthony Peter Tumolo was 14 when he vanished from his Philadelphia neighborhood on October 15, 1966. He was a paperboy for the Philadelphia Inquirer who had spent the day with his best friend, Jack Marino, delivering papers, eating doughnuts and riding bikes. Anthony, 5 feet 2 inches and 110 pounds with black hair, brown eyes and a scar on his right cheek, was last seen leaving home on his bicycle to ride to Jack’s house; he never arrived and was not seen again.

Anthony’s family reported him missing the next day after customers called to say their newspapers weren’t delivered. Police initially treated the case as a probable runaway after a reported sighting by classmates, a story later admitted to be false. Anthony had left personal items, an uncashed paycheck and cash at home, and his bicycle was never found. Jack, who later became a police officer, has long suspected a hit-and-run and notes nearby Interstate 95 construction as a possible place someone could have concealed a body.

Anyone who knew Anthony, his routes, or the neighborhood in 1966 is asked to share what they remember.