Sixteen-year-old Kimberly Arrington left her Montgomery, Alabama, home about 5:00 p.m. on October 30, 1998 to walk to the CVS at Forest Avenue and Third Street for candy and a soda and never returned. She was a sophomore at Jefferson Davis High School, described as well-behaved, a good student who liked computers, and known for being friendly and trusting. Her parents reported her missing around 8:00 p.m. when she failed to come home by 5:45 and could not be found after neighborhood searches.

Investigators canvassed the route to the pharmacy but found no sign of a struggle or Kimberly’s belongings. There were no surveillance cameras at that CVS in 1998 and employees did not recall seeing her, so it is unclear whether she reached the store. The FBI joined the case a year later; they said they found no evidence of foul play but also did not believe she had run away. Rumors that she left with an older man were never substantiated. No solid leads or credible witnesses have emerged.

Does anyone who lived near Forest Avenue and Third Street in 1998 recall seeing Kimberly or anything unusual that afternoon?