Michelle Lynn Benjamin, 35 and a mother of five, disappeared from her Madison Street home in St. Marys, Pennsylvania on the afternoon of June 22, 2007. Witnesses reported seeing her that day with three men who were believed to be from the Buffalo, New York area. It’s thought she may have left in a red or maroon 1992 Buick sedan, possibly headed toward Buffalo.

Michelle is described as a white female with long, straight, strawberry-blonde hair and blue eyes; she was 5 feet 7 inches and about 130 pounds at the time. She has multiple tattoos, including a butterfly on her chest and a moon on her left leg, plus tattoos on her left ankle, left calf and right breast. She had used the married names Dilley and Klawuhn in prior years.

Her disappearance was investigated by the St. Marys Police Department and the Pennsylvania State Police; investigators noted the lack of contact with her children and family was out of character and called the circumstances suspicious. Law enforcement has continued to seek public tips and has at times offered a reward. Does anyone have information about Michelle’s movements on June 22, 2007, or about a red or maroon 1992 Buick sedan seen in the area that day?