Evelyn Grace Hartley, 15, disappeared from La Crosse, Wisconsin, on the evening of October 24, 1953, while babysitting at the Rasmussen home. Her father found the house locked with lights and the radio on; one broken shoe and her broken glasses were inside. Outside, the other shoe lay near footprints and bloodstains, and the window had been forced open.

A large search including volunteers and the National Guard followed; bloodhounds tracked her scent briefly but lost it. Various suspects and reported sightings were later checked but produced no confirmed leads.

Does anyone remember Evelyn or have information about that night?