Carol Susan Hurtubise was 41 when she was shot dead at her home in Tulsa on October 17, 1994. Two young men approached the house at 506 E. 59th Place North that evening; Carol’s 18-year-old son answered the door and was confronted by the pair, who demanded money. Carol, a mother of seven and a school bus driver for Tulsa Public Schools, went to the front door and was struck by a single gunshot to the throat as she stood in the doorway.

The suspects were described as Black male teens. One was about 5 feet 5 inches and 135 pounds, wearing a red and white striped shirt, shorts, and a hat. The other was about 5 feet 9 inches and 120 pounds, wearing a black t-shirt and blue overalls. No arrests have been made and the case remains open with the Tulsa Police Department seeking tips.

If anyone has information about that night or remembers seeing these individuals near 59th Place North on October 17, 1994, please contact the Tulsa Police Department.