On the evening of September 25, 2012, 29-year-old Chad Falling stepped outside his Northwest 9th Street home in Oklahoma City with his common-law wife, Cindy Sanders, after giving a ride to 19-year-old Jerrica Nicole Moore and a man described as her boyfriend. A returning vehicle brought the boyfriend back to the scene, an argument began at the intersection of NW 9th Street and Santa Fe Avenue, and the dispute escalated into a physical fight between Falling and the boyfriend.

Witnesses say Moore came over with a knife during the struggle and lunged at Falling. He managed to knock her down, but she got up and stabbed him once in the chest. Falling was taken to a hospital and died shortly afterward. Moore fled the scene but was identified on surveillance video and arrested on October 3, 2012; she was charged with his murder. The boyfriend is described as a key figure in instigating the fight, and the house at 910 NW 9th Street was later demolished.

Did anyone in the neighborhood see the argument or know the identities of the boyfriend or other witnesses present that night?