Phoenicia Dorsey was 19 when she and 20-year-old Deyonta Dunn were found fatally shot in the living room of a home at 6923 E. Tecumseh Street in Tulsa. Police responded to a 911 call just before midnight on November 1, 2012, and investigators concluded both victims likely died late on Halloween night or in the early hours of November 1. There were no signs of forced entry or a struggle, and detectives say that points to the victims knowing their attacker.

Phoenicia and Deyonta had been seen together in her Saturn Vue on Halloween; the vehicle was later found completely burned in nearby Turley. Investigators have suggested Deyonta, who had a criminal history, may have been the intended target and have called the killings not random. Despite circumstantial leads and the belief that witnesses exist, no arrests have been announced and the case has gone cold.

If anyone has information about Phoenicia, Deyonta, the burned Saturn Vue, or the events of Halloween night 2012, please come forward.