On or around Halloween night 2012, 20-year-old Deyonta Dunn and 19-year-old Phoenicia Dorsey were found shot to death inside a home at 6923 E. Tecumseh St. in Tulsa, Oklahoma. Dunn’s brother made the discovery on November 1 after he could not reach him. Investigators estimated the deaths occurred up to 24 hours earlier and found no signs of forced entry or a struggle, prompting the belief the victims likely knew their killer.

Neighbors reported no gunshots or unusual activity. The last confirmed sighting of the pair was Halloween night in Dorsey’s Saturn Vue; that vehicle was later found burned in Turley, Oklahoma. Dunn had a prior criminal record and had appeared on the Tulsa Police Most Wanted list in 2011 for pointing a deadly weapon and firearm possession, and investigators have suggested Dunn may have been the intended target rather than victims of a random attack. No arrests have been announced and the case remains cold.

Anyone with information about Deyonta Dunn, Phoenicia Dorsey, the burned Saturn Vue, or the events of Halloween night 2012 is asked to come forward.