Amy Sue Pagnac was 13 when she disappeared from a Holiday gas station in Osseo, Minnesota, on August 5, 1989. She had been riding with her stepfather, Marshall Midden, after a day trip to the family farm in Isanti County; Midden went inside the station around 4:30 PM to use the restroom and when he returned Amy was gone. There were no witnesses to confirm she was at the station that day, and authorities were unable to independently verify her presence apart from Midden’s account.

Amy was described as petite, 5 feet tall and about 100 pounds, with brown hair and blue eyes. She had a history of medical issues including seizures, which raised concern that she might have wandered off disoriented; she also had a pattern of running away in the past but always returned quickly. The case was later reclassified as a non-family abduction and has remained unsolved despite searches, a renewed search of the family home and farm in 2014, and continued investigation by the Maple Grove Police Department. Amy’s family has held out hope and her mother has voiced concern she may have been abducted and possibly trafficked.

Anyone who remembers Amy that day or has information about her disappearance is asked to come forward.