John McCulley, 34, went missing from Bazetta Township, Ohio, after failing to keep several scheduled appointments on September 26, 1992. His girlfriend raised the alarm when he did not return from work; McCulley managed All Souls Cemetery and his vehicle was found parked there with no sign of him.

About three weeks later, on October 17, 1992, a hunter found McCulley’s body in the woods behind All Souls Cemetery. He had been shot to death. The Bazetta Police Department has led the homicide investigation with assistance from the Ohio Bureau of Criminal Investigation, but no arrests or public suspect identifications have been announced and the case remains unsolved.

Anyone who knew McCulley, saw him around September 26, 1992, or has information about activity near All Souls Cemetery that fall is asked to contact the investigating agencies.