Jeffrey Allen Stutton, known as Jeff and Jeffrow, was 46 when he left his Columbus, Ohio, home in the 900 block of Hodges Drive about noon on October 9, 2005, to walk to a nearby corner store for cigarettes and never returned. He used two lower-leg prosthetics and could manage short distances, so the errand was within his usual capability. His family says it was highly uncharacteristic for him to leave without telling anyone and he made no further contact.

Stutton is described as a White male, brown hair, brown eyes, five feet two inches, about 100 pounds. He was a double amputee below the knees, missing four fingertips on his left hand, had skin grafts on his left arm and upper legs, a pierced left ear, and tattoos including a dagger on his left shoulder, a bleeding rose on his inner right forearm, and a cross on the outer left forearm. He was believed to be wearing a green army jacket and a Cleveland Browns hat and typically carried a knife and a billfold on a long chain. He required medication for a medical condition.

The Columbus Division of Police handled the investigation but few details emerged and no solid leads were reported. Family members distributed fliers and searched areas he might frequent without success, and the case later grew cold. Does anyone in Columbus remember seeing Jeffrey around October 9, 2005, or have information about his movements that day?