Theodore McMahon was found dead in Dayton, Ohio, on November 3, 1997. Montgomery County authorities classified his death as a homicide, and the death was attributed to an unknown assailant. The Dayton Police Department has handled the investigation and no suspects have been publicly identified.

The Ohio Attorney General’s Office has included McMahon’s case in a cold-case initiative that publicizes unsolved homicides to encourage tips. Crime Stoppers also seeks information from anyone who might know details about what happened that day. If anyone has information that could help resolve Theodore McMahon’s homicide, please contact the Dayton Police Department, Crime Stoppers, or the Attorney General’s tip line.