Gary Hayward, 36, disappeared from Poipu on Kauai after an evening at the Poipu Shores Bar, often dated as May 2, 1987. He was a Caucasian man, 5 feet 11 inches, about 185–188 pounds, with brown hair beginning to gray, a beard, blue eyes and a scar on his right knee. That night he was wearing a white t-shirt, blue cut-off shorts and tennis shoes. He reportedly told someone at the bar he wanted to go for a swim; that was the last known communication before he failed to return to the condominium where he was staying.

His disappearance was reported to the Kauai Police Department a couple of days later. If anyone was in Poipu that evening or remembers seeing Gary after he left the bar, please share what you know with the Kauai Police Department.