Shelly Sue Turner, 38, was last seen on a late September evening in 2006 in Dayton, Ohio. She had been at Slugs Tavern on Smithville Road with her fiancé, Harold Baker. After that night her life vanishes into conflicting accounts: she left behind two young sons, including an infant, all her personal belongings, a Ford Explorer and her last paycheck. Her debit card showed no activity after she disappeared.

Descriptions list Shelly as a white female, long straight blonde hair with bangs, blue eyes, about 5 feet 5 inches tall, 170 pounds, with a lower abdominal scar from a Cesarean section; she wore contacts or plastic-framed eyeglasses and was last seen in blue jeans. Baker told police that Shelly saw a man named Bill in a gray Pontiac Grand Am, gave back her engagement ring and left with him. Family and friends disputed that account, saying Shelly would not have abandoned her children and that she had spoken about ending the relationship.

The Dayton Police Department treated the case as involving possible foul play as searches continued without resolution. Shelly’s body has not been found. Does anyone who was in or near Slugs Tavern that night remember seeing Shelly, a gray Pontiac Grand Am, or a man named Bill?