Dorothy Goroshko, 40, of Brighton, Massachusetts, was last seen on June 4, 1975, after an evening at The Penalty Box bar near Boston’s North Station. She left the bar, and both she and her gold 1970 Ford Maverick vanished; neither the car nor Dorothy have ever been found despite multiple searches.

At the time she disappeared, Dorothy was dating John Jack Boulton, a convicted felon with a violent history that included a manslaughter conviction. Boulton later said the two argued that night and that Dorothy followed him in her car as he walked home, attempting to hit him with the vehicle. Reports note that his account is inconsistent with other evidence, and authorities have re-examined his role in her disappearance over the years. Dorothy’s family strongly suspects foul play and in 2021 offered a $50,000 reward for information leading to her whereabouts.

What did Dorothy look like that night, who else was at The Penalty Box, or who might have seen that gold 1970 Ford Maverick after June 4, 1975?