Toni Sue Esbenshade, 24, was last seen the night of March 26, 1984, after leaving a tavern in Lockhart, Texas, where she worked part-time as a bartender. She also worked days as an office manager at Bufkin Farms. Toni left her vehicle and personal belongings at home; her estranged husband Roger Esbenshade later said her keys were hanging on the door, her purse was on the porch, and her car was in the driveway the morning after she vanished.

Investigators followed several early leads, including a traveling photographer who had given her a rose at the tavern, but none produced a definitive result. Remains found in Texas were tested at one point and were not identified as Toni. Her disappearance remains unsolved and her family continues to seek answers.

If anyone knew Toni, saw her in Lockhart around March 26–27, 1984, or has information that could help, please come forward.