Barry Sherman, 75, and his wife Honey were found dead inside their Toronto home on December 15, 2017. The couple were discovered in the lower-level pool area, semi-seated on the deck with belts around their necks attached to a low railing; post-mortem exams determined both died from ligature neck compression. Investigators established the pair had last been seen the evening of December 13 and concluded the deaths occurred about then.

Toronto homicide detectives declared both deaths homicides and said the Shermans had been deliberately targeted. There were no obvious signs of forced entry. Police collected nearly 150 exhibits, thousands of hours of nearby security footage, interviewed more than 100 witnesses and examined multiple persons of interest, but did not publicly identify an accused or announce a motive. In December 2021 investigators released surveillance of an unidentified person seen near the home around the time of the killings; the individual was described as about 5 feet 6 3/4 inches to 5 feet 9 1/2 inches tall and was singled out because of a distinctive gait.

Whoever killed Barry and Honey Sherman has not been publicly identified; anyone with information is asked to come forward.