Jehad Alzaben, 47, was shot inside Livingston Market on the 1600 block of East Livingston Avenue just before midnight on May 25, 2025. Officers found him gravely wounded; he was taken to Grant Medical Center and pronounced dead in the early minutes of May 26. Neighbors described him as a storekeeper who watched over the corner, donated to youth sports, and kept a watchful eye on the block.

Detectives used surveillance footage and receipts to retrace the final hour. Video and credit card transactions were cited in the affidavit as matching the timeline.

U.S. Marshals arrested Joshua Norfleet in Coshocton County on June 12, 2025; police said an arrest warrant charged him with murder and he was later extradited to Franklin County for arraignment while detectives continued gathering evidence.