On Christmas Eve 1992 in Prince Edward County, Virginia, 24-year-old George Atkinson Jr was one of four men shot dead inside a home that was then set on fire. Atkinson, who shared the house with his father, and two friends — 31-year-old Jeffrey Villalobos and 24-year-old William B. Cutter — each suffered a fatal gunshot wound to the head before the perpetrators attempted to conceal the crime by burning the residence.

Investigators later identified two brothers, Michael and Johnny Williams, as the individuals who entered the home and killed all four men. Michael Williams was arrested and charged in connection with the murders; Johnny Williams was implicated in the killings. The attack transformed a family home into a crime scene on a holiday that is normally a time for celebration.

Did anyone in Prince Edward County know the victims or have information about the Williams brothers that could shed more light on what happened that night?