Cathleen Dennis was 28 when she went missing in Grand Rapids, Michigan, after arriving there from Omaha, Nebraska, with her sister on Friday, July 7, 1995. The sisters spent the night at a club and later went to the area known as the Division to look for clients. Deanna last saw Cathleen in the early hours of July 10 getting into a light-colored Chevrolet, possibly a 1965–1968 model, at Division Avenue and Putnam Street. Cathleen left behind two young children, then ages seven and eight.

Initial attempts by family to report Cathleen missing were hampered by dismissive responses, so her mother and sisters searched locally and distributed flyers. In early 2024 a convicted killer, Garry Artman, confessed on his deathbed to murdering Cathleen and disposing of her body in a dumpster, saying she had a splint or sling on her arm when he saw her leaving a bar. Investigators believe her remains are unlikely to be recovered.

Did anyone in the Division area in July 1995 remember seeing Cathleen or that light-colored Chevrolet?