On December 10, 1991, five-year-old Tiffany LeighAnn Hall and her mother Teresa Hall, 26, were found dead in Cypress, Jackson County, Florida. Tiffany had been born January 28, 1986, and was just shy of her sixth birthday. Both victims were reportedly bludgeoned to death in what authorities described as a brutal double homicide that shocked the small community.

Investigators initially focused on those closest to the family; Teresa Hall’s husband was considered a person of interest but was later cleared after it was confirmed he had been out of town at the time. Over the years there were claims linking two different serial killers, including Ángel Maturino Reséndiz, to the murders, but those claims were not substantiated and did not result in charges. The case went cold and no arrests were made.

The investigation was reopened in 2020 amid renewed public interest prompted in part by podcasts and online advocacy, and a book titled High Sheriff by Johnny Mac reportedly includes a chapter with previously unreleased information. As of the latest updates, no suspects have been officially named or charged.