Michelle Lea Mace was 16 when she was killed in Clarksville, Tennessee. On the evening of April 23, 1997, she was working a closing shift at a Baskin-Robbins with her 21-year-old co-worker Angela Holmes. When Michelle’s mother arrived to pick her up, the store was empty and the cash drawer was open. Both young women were found dead the next day at Dunbar Cave State Natural Area, each having suffered deep stab wounds to the neck and having bled to death.

Investigators linked the double homicide to Paul Dennis Reid. Witnesses reported seeing a car matching Reid’s near the Baskin-Robbins and at Dunbar Cave, and he was later arrested and charged with the kidnapping, robbery, and murders of Michelle and Angela. Reid was convicted at trial for these murders and several other homicides; multiple death sentences were imposed.

If anyone knew Michelle, where she worked, or saw anything around the Baskin-Robbins or Dunbar Cave on April 23–24, 1997, please share what might help fill gaps in the timeline.