Allen Lee Livingston was 27 when he vanished from Indianapolis on August 6, 1993. Described by family as outgoing and flamboyant, he frequented downtown Indianapolis. His mother, Sharon Livingston, reported him missing and long suspected foul play, feeling her concerns were downplayed because of Allen’s lifestyle and sexual orientation.

In June 1996 investigators searched Fox Hollow Farm in Westfield, Indiana, owned by businessman Herbert Baumeister and found thousands of charred and crushed bone fragments. Eight victims were identified initially; most remains were too damaged for immediate identification. Allen’s family believed he was among the victims buried on the property.

The case moved forward decades later when the Hamilton County coroner reopened the unidentified remains investigation in 2022 and sought family DNA. Sharon Livingston provided a swab before her death from cancer. In October 2023 forensic testing matched a bone fragment from Fox Hollow Farm to Allen, making him the ninth identified victim. Baumeister fled to Ontario in 1996 and died by suicide on July 3, 1996; no trial was ever held.

Did anyone who knew Allen in Indianapolis in 1993 have contact or sightings that could add detail to his last known movements?