Roger Allen Goodlet was a 33-year-old white man who disappeared after an evening at a downtown gay bar on July 22, 1994. Earlier that day he had helped his mother assemble a bench and returned home to play with a new kitten; his failure to come back that night was out of character and prompted friends and family to report him missing. His disappearance became one of several vanishings of gay men in the Indianapolis area in the early 1990s.

Investigators eventually linked Goodlet’s case to Fox Hollow Farm, an eighteen-acre property in Westfield owned by businessman Herbert Richard Baumeister. In June 1996 police unearthed thousands of human bone fragments on the property and recovered remains identified as at least eleven men. Goodlet’s remains were identified first by dental records and later reconfirmed by DNA. Authorities say Baumeister is the prime suspect; an arrest warrant was issued but he fled to Ontario, where he died by suicide in a park near Lake Huron.

Does anyone have memories of Roger, or information about his last night in Indianapolis that could help piece together what happened?