Marjorie Gayle McCaffrey was 36 and a mother of two when she disappeared from her West Ashley home on Limestone Boulevard in Charleston, South Carolina. According to her husband Robert McCaffrey, the couple argued on the afternoon of March 17, 2012; he said he left for a walk, returned to find Gayle unresponsive, left again that evening, and then discovered the next morning that she was gone while their children, ages ten and four, slept. Gayle’s Jeep, cell phone, wallet, checkbook and wedding band were left at the house. A typed goodbye letter saying she intended to be with another man was found but family members questioned its authenticity given Gayle’s devout Baptist faith and church choir involvement.

Robert told police a 350-pound safe holding cash and a gun had been taken, a claim disputed by the daughter and other relatives who said no such safe existed. Investigators later named Robert as the primary suspect and announced in May 2012 they believed Gayle had been murdered. A grand jury declined to indict him for murder in 2018, but a probate judge declared Gayle legally dead that year and held Robert responsible for her estate.

Did anyone in West Ashley at the time see Gayle’s Jeep, or remember unusual activity at the McCaffrey home around March 17, 2012?