On July 5, 2016, 41-year-old James Songer was found dead at his Brock Hollow Road residence in Pikeville, Tennessee, alongside his companion Robbin Martin. Their deaths were not natural, and the Tennessee Bureau of Investigation classified the case as a double homicide. The cause of death has not been released publicly.

The night before, both were seen at Fourth of July events in nearby Dunlap; the local sheriff saw them drive by and noted a third person in the vehicle, an unidentified man who remains a focus of the investigation though no description has been released. The trailer the couple lived in has since burned down, further complicating the inquiry. No suspects have been publicly identified or arrested, and the case has gone cold.

Did anyone in Pikeville or Dunlap see that vehicle or the unidentified man the evening of July 4, 2016?