James Turner, 44, was found shot inside a car on New Harmony Road in Hartsville, Tennessee, on the night of February 11, 2017. Turner, described as generous and willing to help others, died at the scene. Also in the vehicle was 32-year-old Alisha Renee Mondoni, who survived the initial shooting but died later that morning.

Investigators concluded the killings were a case of mistaken identity. The shooters were reportedly seeking Turner’s nephew, Steven Turner Jr.; when they could not find him, they opened fire on James Turner and Mondoni in the driveway. Authorities identified Keithandre Murray as the primary suspect and said an accomplice, Rodney Garrett, aided him.

Both Murray and Garrett were arrested and indicted by the Macon County Grand Jury. In 2019 a jury convicted Keithandre Murray of two counts of first-degree premeditated murder, and in 2020 Rodney Garrett was convicted on two counts of facilitation of first-degree murder. Did anyone in Hartsville know either victim or have information about that night?