In the early morning of September 19, 2015, 31-year-old security guard Corey Bryan was shot and killed outside Vinny’s Good Times Bar on Reinoehl Street in Lebanon, Pennsylvania. The shooting followed a dispute inside the nightclub: two patrons were ejected after an argument involving Bryan. Shortly after being removed, one of the men returned to the bar’s entrance and fired shots through the exit door as the establishment was closing. Bryan was struck in the abdomen and later died at a local hospital. A 37-year-old woman was also wounded in the hip and sustained non-life-threatening injuries.

Investigators identified 24-year-old Richard Kinnard II as the shooter and 25-year-old Jared D. Jones as the getaway driver. Both men were arrested in January 2016—Kinnard in Tucson, Arizona, and Jones in a Hershey hotel—and were brought back to Pennsylvania to face charges including criminal homicide, conspiracy, and aggravated assault. What details about the shooting or those present that night might help explain how the confrontation escalated to gunfire?