Victor Buddy Wilson Jr., 40, was shot and killed outside The Malibu Club in South Coatesville in the early hours of September 30, 2017. Wilson, a produce manager at an Acme Market, had been celebrating a promotion when an argument at the club entrance with another man escalated into a physical altercation. Witnesses said the pair agreed to a fistfight, but the other man produced an unlicensed handgun, shot Wilson multiple times and then fired additional rounds after Wilson fell. An autopsy recorded five gunshot wounds to the head and torso; Wilson was pronounced dead at the scene.

Multiple witnesses identified 28-year-old Dominic Buddha Poulson, whose Cut Throat Family tattoos and a sweatshirt linked to that group were noted by investigators. Authorities later charged Poulson in connection with the killing, alleging the motive was that he felt disrespected after being pushed. At trial the defense said Poulson believed Wilson was reaching for a box cutter, though no weapon was recovered. The jury convicted Poulson of third-degree murder and illegal possession of a firearm; he received a 20 to 40 year sentence.

Did anyone who was at The Malibu Club that night notice anything about how the argument began or anyone who left the scene immediately afterward?