Paige Nikole Kibe, 25, was found dead on River Road in Bratton Township, Pennsylvania on December 16, 2022. The Pennsylvania State Police determined she died of multiple gunshot wounds. At the scene she was holding a pair of black-framed glasses and a black knit cap was located behind her; two cell phones were also recovered and were used to trace her movements and identify suspects.

Investigators say two men were identified as primary suspects. Michael Jason Kennedy, 44, of Yeagertown, was arrested December 21, 2022 and charged with criminal homicide, aggravated assault, kidnapping and other counts; he is being held without bail. A second man, 26-year-old Trevor Alan Middaugh of Lewistown, turned himself in January 4, 2023 after a warrant and faces charges including criminal homicide, criminal conspiracy, aggravated assault and kidnapping.

Police reports allege Kennedy and Middaugh conspired to kill Kibe because they suspected she had stolen guns from one of them. A witness told investigators they saw the two with Kibe at the boat launch where her body was found, heard two gunshots after the men questioned her about the guns, and said Kennedy was running the show; the witness also reported being warned to stay silent. Does anyone have information about Paige’s last movements or who she was with that day?