Keith Robert Anderson was 22 when he went to a horse barn in the Hot Sulphur Springs area of Grand County, Colorado, on February 5, 1984, and was never seen again. His truck was found idling near the barn with his German Shepherd in the back, and some of Keith’s blood was later recovered inside the barn, including blood reported on manure. Witnesses in the area reported hearing several gunshots around the time he vanished.

The barn was owned by Vernon Spud Weaver, whose .44 caliber magnum was reported missing the day after Keith disappeared and was reportedly found months later too rusted to link to ballistics evidence. Reports also note a .44 caliber bullet was found in Keith’s horse, which died two days later, and a witness said Buttel’s truck was seen near Anderson’s ranch with something wrapped in blankets in the back.

No charges have been filed and Keith’s remains have not been found. Did anyone in the Hot Sulphur Springs or Illinois area have contact with Keith or David Buttel around February 1984 that could help resolve what happened?