Andrew Cunningham, 26, was shot to death on January 4, 2008, in the Oakley neighborhood of Cincinnati. The killing became a high-profile homicide investigation as police worked to identify the perpetrators.

Marcus Sapp was convicted of Cunningham’s murder in 2010, a verdict that rested in part on testimony from a jailhouse informant, Quincy Jones, and other evidence presented at trial. In January 2023 a Hamilton County judge ordered a new trial, finding significant errors in the original investigation and noting that audio recordings and investigative notes had not been disclosed to Sapp’s defense. Those materials reportedly showed that a surviving victim and a confidential informant had identified another suspect who was never tried.

In May 2024 prosecutors dropped the murder charges against Marcus Sapp, citing unavailable key witnesses and loss of important evidence over time, while saying they still believed Sapp was responsible but could not successfully reprosecute the case. The true perpetrators remain at large. Did anyone in Oakley at the time notice anything or have information that could help reopen leads?