Dontai Lamar Davis Rheubottom, a 33-year-old Black man, was one of three people fatally shot on August 19, 2015, at the Shaker Square Apartments in Whitehall, Ohio. The other victims were 51-year-old Kimberli Alston and 32-year-old Charles Fischer. Police treated the deaths as connected and witnesses said the gunman fled in a vehicle; detectives later identified a white Dodge Charger as a suspected getaway car.

Investigators developed 19-year-old Daveron Minnis as a suspect and traced the Charger to Jamaica, Queens, where New York officers located the vehicle and arrested Minnis on August 25, 2015. He was returned to Ohio and later indicted in January 2017 on multiple counts tied to the killings, which prosecutors described as occurring during a drug-related robbery. Despite the arrest and indictment, the Ohio Attorney General’s cold-case listing still classifies Rheubottom’s homicide as unsolved under state case number 3797.

Anyone with information about the August 19, 2015 shootings or the white Dodge Charger is asked to come forward.