Jerry Williams-Comer, 34, of Indianapolis, was last seen August 8, 1995. His vehicle was later found abandoned in the Castleton Square Mall parking lot and there has been no confirmed contact or trace of him since. The case remains an open missing person investigation.

Authorities have noted that Williams-Comer fit the profile of several young men linked to Herb Baumeister, a suspect connected to multiple deaths of men in the Indianapolis area in the 1990s who targeted men in the LGBTQ+ community and frequented gay bars. Williams-Comer’s remains were not found on Baumeister’s property, and Baumeister died by suicide in 1996, leaving gaps in several investigations.

Anyone who knew Jerry, saw him around August 8, 1995, or has information about his car being left at Castleton Square Mall is asked to come forward.