Nathaniel Davis, a 29-year-old from Cincinnati, Ohio, was one of two people killed in a shooting outside the Rustic Tavern in College Hill on September 23, 2018. The early morning altercation began inside the bar and spilled outside, where Davis and 28-year-old Steven Anderson Jr. were both shot and died at the scene.

Police arrested two suspects in the case, Jonathan Patton and Maurice Searcy, and both faced murder charges. The case drew attention because of claimed inconsistencies in witness accounts and assertions by Patton’s attorney that investigators suppressed evidence. Patton maintained his innocence but later entered a plea that resulted in a reduced sentence.

The deaths of Davis and Anderson had a lasting impact on their families and the community. Does anyone have information about that night outside the Rustic Tavern or about either victim’s movements beforehand?